Ice Cream Factory’s Most Underrated Flavors

Since the very beginning, Ice Cream Factory has built a loyal fan base thanks to our high-quality ice cream and unforgettable flavors. Once people get a taste, they’re hooked. Our retailers keep coming back, too, because our ice cream doesn’t sit on shelves for long. 

While most people know us for our fan-favorite flavors like Gooey Butter Cake, Blackberry Cobbler, and Strawberry Cheesecake, we’ve created dozens of delicious varieties over the years. Some were seasonal hits like Peach Cobbler and Apple Pie, which many say taste even better than the real thing. 

And yes, we’ve had a few wild experiments along the way. Pickle Split, Pizza, and Maple Bacon were bold ideas that didn’t quite win the crowd (we like to call them… character-building flavors…Haha!). But that’s the beauty of creativity—you try, you learn, and sometimes, you land on a hidden gem. 

Maple Bacon: The Flavor Flop That Still Gets People Talking!

Today, we want to spotlight a few flavors that did stick but haven’t gotten the spotlight they deserve. These underrated flavors might be overshadowed by the hype of our famous ones, but they’re made with the same premium ingredients, fresh bakery inclusions, and small-batch care. They’re delicious, and it’s time you gave them a chance. 

Coconut Almond Paradise 

Coconut Almond Paradise Coconut ice cream with almonds and chocolate coconut pieces 

A scoop of this and you’re instantly on island time. Our creamy coconut base is smooth and refreshing. Crunchy roasted almonds and chocolate coconut pieces are mixed throughout generously, adding texture and richness to every bite.

Who would’ve thought coconut and chocolate could taste this good together? It’s tropical, nutty, chocolatey bliss. Coconut Almond Paradise is also DAIRY FREE. And yes, it’s as dreamy as it sounds.  

Blueberry Shortcake Blueberry ice cream with a scrumptious blueberry swirl and handmade shortcake pieces in every bite!

Blueberry Shortcake 

This flavor is pure nostalgia in every bite. Fresh, fluffy shortcake chunks, baked in our own bakery, are folded into a silky-smooth cream base.

Swirls of blueberries that burst with fruity flavor. It’s soft, creamy, buttery, and berry-packed all in one bite. This flavor smells as amazing as it tastes; A treat for all your senses. 

Cherry ChocolatE Chunk 

Cherry Chocolate Chunk Cherry ice cream with fudge brownie chunks and a cherry swirl 

Chocolate cream with fudge brownie chunks and a cherry swirl. This one is rich, bold, and perfectly balanced. We start with our smooth chocolate ice cream…

Think classic chocolate but even creamier, then load it with soft, fudgy brownie chunks made right in our bakery. To top it off, we swirl in bright, tangy cherry ribbon that cuts through the richness with just the right pop of fruit.  It is like the perfect Brownie Sundae with cherry topping! 

Chocolate Caramel Espresso

Chocolate Caramel Espresso Coffee Ice Cream with a Caramel Fudge Swirl and Chocolate Covered Espresso Bean Flakes.

This one’s like your favorite coffeehouse treat but frozen, richer, and somehow even more satisfying. The bold espresso base gives you a real caffeine kick, while ribbons of buttery caramel and melt-in-your-mouth fudge chunks take it to dessert-level indulgence. It’s smooth, sweet, salty, and strong—all in one addictive flavor.

Warning: one spoonful and your 12oz container might not make it to tomorrow. 

Give the Underdogs a Chance  

It’s time to branch out, friends! These underrated flavors are proof that sometimes, the best things aren’t always the most talked about. Each one is packed with the same premium quality, handmade inclusions, and unforgettable flavor you expect from Ice Cream Factory. 

Which one will you try first? 

Get Them Before They’re Gone

Our 12oz containers of these hidden gems won’t be around forever—so now’s your chance to discover something new.

👉 Mix and match your favourites with our Farewell 4 Pack and grab them before they’re gone!

ORDER NOW & SHIP TO MY DOORSTEP